Uber Drivers are Employees

Thomas M. Lee

Uber has long tried to play itself off as simply a middleman, just dispatching independent drivers to consumers through its app — and taking a big cut of their fare. Nothing but logistics, right? Not according to the California Labor Commission, who ruled today that the extensive control Uber has over its drivers makes them employees, not independent contractors.

The ruling is a major blow to the company, which has long resisted classifying its drivers as employees. Treating drivers as employees will require Uber to pay for Social Security, workers compensation, unemployment insurance, work expenses and other costs, all of which have been borne by drivers until now.

Uber’s Dependence on and Control Over Drivers

The Commission’s ruling comes after an Uber driver, Barbara Berwick, filed a complaint alleging Uber owed her unpaid wages, reimbursement for work expenditures, and waiting time penalties. Central to the Commission’s decision was the fact that Uber’s drivers are “not engaged in occupations or businesses distinct from that” of Uber. Their work is the basis of Uber’s business and Uber retains “pervasive control over the operation as a whole,” even if some details are left to the drivers. From determining what cars drivers can use, to what fares are to be paid, to whether drivers can accept tips, Uber was involved in “every aspect of the operation.” As the Commission noted, “without drivers such as Plaintiff, Defendant’s business would cease to exist.”

The implications of the ruling on Uber are enormous. Having driven for just eight weeks, Berwick was owed almost $4,000 for expenses — had she worked a year with the same rate of expenses, she would be owed nearly $24,000.

That number doesn’t include FICA taxes, costs of insurance and other benefits that Uber would be required to cover for its employees, either. For a company with thousands of drivers in California and over a million throughout the world, the Commission’s ruling isn’t just a liability, it’s a blow to its very business model. Uber is sure to appeal the decision and is currently fighting off a driver class action which asserts similar claims.

Undermining the Basis of the On-Demand Economy?

Uber’s business model is not unique — indeed, it’s been taken up by dozens of “on-demand” tech start ups, who sent out valets, house cleaners, dog walkers and delivery services with the touch of an app. Almost all of them classify those workers are independent contractors, requiring the workers to bear the burden of self-employment taxes, insurance, and work-related expenses.

Many app-based on-demand companies exert a Uber-esque level of control over, and dependence upon those workers. Those companies have brought in billions of dollars while operating outside the constraints of traditional employers. Should the Commission’s logic apply to those companies as well, or should other regulators take a similar position, the basis of the industry could come into question.

Most companies probably wouldn’t go up in smoke, according to The Washington Post, but they would see a drastic decline in profits.

Please note that the information I am providing here in this entry, or in my website is NOT to be construed as legal advice nor is it meant to form an attorney-client relationship. For a free legal consultation by phone, please call or email me anytime.

Client Reviews

Mr. Lee is extremely knowledgeable when it comes to employment law. I was amazed by his tenacity and skill and in the end, I walked away with a settlement I was very happy about. I highly recommended him to anyone.

Sarah G.

Earlier this year I was very confused about a legal employer/employee situation and needed professional advice. In my desire to move quickly on my situation I spent hours signing up for legal services (e.g. legal shield...

Richard H., Los Angeles, CA

Hands down, the best immigration lawyer in Los Angeles that you could possibly find. Period. After an extremely poor experience with another law firm, which had come highly recommended by one of my company's attorneys...

Robert K., Beverly Hills, CA

My old company was breaking some labor laws and I decided to look for some legal advice. I went to Tom to see what course of action I can take and when we sat down to talk about the details, I decided to hire him and his...

Ethan Y., Orange, CA

It's quite rare to find a lawyer that sincerely cares about your best interest. Most employment lawyers are extremely hungry for business which makes them naturally have their best interest not mine. However, Tom truly...

Jen T., Central LA, Los Angeles, CA

Get in Touch

  1. 1 Free Consultation
  2. 2 Decades of Experience
  3. 3 High Success Record
Fill out the contact form or call us at (213) 251-5533 to schedule your free consultation.

Leave Us a Message